Library Catalog - Fusion! Electronic Resources Course/E-Reserves Interlibrary Loan Library Guides New Items
Students Faculty Distance Learning Students Library Users with Disabilities
Ask A Librarian Email a Librarian Subject Specialists Attend Online Sessions EndNote Download
Staff Directory Directions to the ISU Library Hours & Calendar Library Faculty Assembly Library Catalogs of Vigo County Library Documents Employment Library Home Page
Special Collections Sycamore Scholars Reference/Instruction Wabash Valley Visions & Voices University Archives Borrowing
Request item on order or just received Get off-campus access to databases Use the library printers Check my library account Request Media for a Class or Program Visitors-School Groups Circulation Policies
Search:    
Evaluating Articles Tutorial

Introduction

Types of Articles

Format/Structure

Author

Language

Illustrations/ Advertisements

Purpose

Audience

Peer Reviewed/ Refereed

Printable Checklist

 

 blue line 

Printable Checklist

Below are listed differences between scholarly and popular publications. If you have any difficulty determining if a publication is popular or scholarly, ask a librarian for assistance.

Scholarly Sources

Have a somber, "scholarly" look
Sources are always cited
Bibliography or reference page
Authors have educational/professional background to write on topic
Language is "jargon" of the discipline
Very few ads -- mostly for employment
May contain charts, graphs
Report on original research or experiments
Articles are geared toward professionals in the field
Articles are "reviewed," "peer reviewed" or "refereed"
Found in libraries/research centers
In-depth articles may be several pages long
Published monthly, quarterly, annually

Popular Sources

Attractive cover
Many advertisements for products
Paper is "slick and glossy"
Language is easy to understand
No discipline "jargon" language
Articles are short -- no in-depth coverage on topic
Articles are geared toward the general public
Articles are written by reporters, staff -- not experts
No bibliography
Found at bookstores, newsstands, grocery stores
Published weekly/monthly

Sensational Sources

Author information (education, etc) is not listed
No bibliography or references
Language is very easy to read
Photographs may be in color or black and white
Often in newspaper form
Information in articles cannot be verified
Contains ads for products

Substantive News/General Interest

Author information rarely listed
No bibliography or references provided
Language is geared toward a basic (high school) education
Numerous color photographs
Ads for products
Content is current news/hot topics

Trade Publications

Contains "jargon" language for specific trades
Contains color or black and white photographs
Contains ads for products
Author information is usually not provided
Rarely contains bibliographic or reference sources

Getting Assistance

If you cannot determine if an article is popular or scholarly, ask a librarian for assistance.

The following sources can help you determine if the source is scholarly or popular:

Ulrich's Periodicals Directory
http://www.ulrichsweb.com/

Magazines for Libraries
Call number: Z 6941 .K 2 2002
Reference Desk, First Floor

<<< back      

September 19th, 2003